Advisory in the AI Age: Navigating the “Consulting Crash”

 

The Erosion of Traditional Advisory Models

The age‑old consulting model—anchored in billable hours and labor‑intensive analysis—is cracking under the weight of AI. Automation of repetitive tasks isn’t horizon‑bound; it’s here. Major firms are bracing:

  • Big Four upheaval — Up to 50% of advisory, audit, and tax roles could vanish in the next few years as AI reshapes margin models and deliverables.
  • McKinsey’s existential shift — AI now enables data analysis and presentation generation in minutes. The firm has restructured around outcome‑based partnerships, with 25% of work tied to tangible business results.
  • “Consulting crash” looming — AI efficiencies combined with contracting policy changes are straining consulting profitability across the board.

ChatGPT Image Aug 11 2025 at 11 41 36 AM

AI‑Infused Advisory: What Real‑World Looks Like

Consulting is no longer just human‑driven—AI is embedded:

  • AI agent swarms — Internal use of thousands of AI agents allows smaller teams to deliver more with less.
  • Generative intelligence at scale — Firm‑specific assistants (knowledge chatbots, slide generators, code copilots) accelerate research, design, and delivery.

Operational AI beats demo AI. The winners aren’t showing prototypes; they’re wiring models into CI/CD, decision flows, controls, and telemetry.

From Billable Hours to Outcome‑Based Value

As AI commoditizes analysis, control shifts to strategic interpretation and execution. That forces a pricing and packaging rethink:

  • Embed, don’t bolt‑on — Architect AI into core processes and guardrails; avoid one‑off reports that age like produce.
  • Price to outcomes — Tie a clear portion of fees to measurable impact: cycle time reduced, error rate dropped, revenue lift captured.
  • Own runbooks — Codify delivery with reference architectures, safety controls, and playbooks clients can operate post‑engagement.

Practical Playbook: Navigating the AI‑Driven Advisory Landscape

  1. Client triage — Segment work into automate (AI‑first), augment (human‑in‑the‑loop), and advise (judgment‑heavy). Push commoditized tasks toward automation; preserve people for interpretation and change‑management.
  2. Infrastructure & readiness audits — Assess data quality, access controls, lineage, model governance, and observability. If the substrate is weak, modernize before strategy.
  3. Outcome‑based offers — Convert packages into fixed‑fee + success components. Define KPIs, timeboxes, and stop‑loss logic up front.
  4. Forward‑Deployed Engineers (FDEs) — Embed build‑capable consultants inside client teams to ship operational AI, not just recommendations.
  5. Lean Rationalism — Apply Lean IT to advisory delivery: remove handoff waste, shorten feedback loops, productize templates, and use automation to erase bureaucratic overhead.

Why This Matters

This isn’t a passing disruption—it’s a structural inflection. Whether you’re solo or running a boutique, the path is clear: dismantle antiquated billing models, anchor on outcomes, and productize AI‑augmented value creation. Otherwise, the market will do the dismantling for you.

Support My Work

Support the creation of high-impact content and research. Sponsorship opportunities are available for specific topics, whitepapers, tools, or advisory insights. Learn more or contribute here: Buy Me A Coffee


References

  1. AI and Trump put consulting firms under pressure — Axios
  2. As AI Comes for Consulting, McKinsey Faces an “Existential” Shift — Wall Street Journal
  3. AI is coming for the Big Four too — Business Insider
  4. Consulting’s AI Transformation — IBM Institute for Business Value
  5. Closing the AI Impact Gap — BCG
  6. Because of AI, Consultants Are Now Expected to Do More — Inc.
  7. AI Transforming the Consulting Industry — Geeky Gadgets

* AI tools were used as a research assistant for this content, but human moderation and writing are also included. The included images are AI-generated.

 

Leave a comment